A Survey of Quadratization Methods Used in QUBO Formulations and their Usage in Quantum and Digital Annealing

Abstract

Quantum annealing is a metaheuristic method aimed at finding the global minimum of a pseudo-Boolean quadratic function. To solve a problem by a quantum annealer, it must be restated as a QUBO (quadratic unconstrained binary optimization) problem, the standard format acceptable to an annealer. However, there are many natural problems that turn out be of cubic or higher order, yet promising solutions can be obtained for many instances using quantum annealers, after converting to the QUBO format, using order reduction criteria. Accordingly, quadratization becomes a crucial preprocessing step in order to make use of present-day quantum annealing hardware that relies on coupling technology, which can only process interactions of at most degree two. A critical challenge is that quadratization methods often require many additional variables, degrading the performance of the annealers. A number of algorithmic and heuristic quadratization techniques have been proposed and used for annealing in the literature, affecting the performance of the annealers differently. We examine a number of such quadratization techniques, focusing on their efficiency, compactness, and applicability. We analyze the approaches motivated by diverse goals and highlight the transition from foundational approaches to more recent compact approaches. An evaluation of the current usage of different quadratization methods in the literature is carried out at the end of the survey. Further, we comment on the limitations on usage and show possible opportunities to enhance the performance of annealers.